Can devotee ladies marry men who are not devotees?

One problem we have in our movement (and in modern society in general) is that it is difficult for women to find a proper husband and become settled in family life. What to do about it?

One problem we have in our movement (and in modern society in general) is that it is difficult for women to find a proper husband and become settled in family life. There are of course many men interested in associating with ladies, but when it comes the time to accept responsibilities, most of them shy away. We see that even qualified ladies frequently find it difficult to get married. Another problem is that getting married is also not a guarantee of anything, since divorces are also very common. Even if a lady does find a husband, there is no guarantee that this man will stay her whole life with her.

In traditional societies, association with ladies is conditioned to marriage. If a man wants a lady, he has to get a wife and accept responsibility for maintaining a family. In modern societies, however, men and women associate freely, and this reduces the number of people interested in entering into a stable relationship. As Prabhupada explains, one will not want to maintain a cow if he can just get milk from the market.

Theoretically, we are supposed to be traditional in our movement, with marriage being the only acceptable way of having a loving relationship, but we can see that in practice we more or less follow the general culture, with people dating and entering into relationships without necessarily having the intention of getting married. In this way, the problem ends up affecting us in the same way it affects people from the outside.

Another problem is that nowadays we have more ladies than men coming to our movement. In some countries, the proportion may still be more or less the same, but when we take it globally, especially in countries like China and Russia, there are definitely more women than men. Ideally, devotees should marry devotees, and a lady should try to marry a man who is more mature, and more spiritually advanced than herself, who can guide her on the path back to Godhead. However, we can see that nowadays this is quite rare. Most ladies have to choose between marrying whatever devotee man is available, marrying someone from the outside, or risking remaining single for life.

In such a situation, many ladies end up marrying men who are not devotees. I used to think of this as a terrible thing, but over the years I saw a few cases that changed my opinion to a certain extent.

We frequently think of the division between "devotees" and "non-devotees" as a black-and-white distinction, but in reality, it is more like a multitude of gradations of gray. Not all "devotees" are very pious or devotional, and not all "non-devotees" are completely bad. We can frequently see that devotees often show quite negative qualities, while some "non-devotees" are actually quite pious and good-natured. Usually, these are people who are not atheists, but "spiritual but not religious" people who have some faith in God, but don't identify with any particular religious process, or who are non-practicing Christians or Muslims. Such men often value having a wife who is serious about practicing a spiritual process, even if they themselves are not practicing. This can lead to workable marriages, where the husband supports the lady in her practice and is favorable to the children receiving spiritual education, even while he is not directly practicing. The tendency in such families, however, is that gradually the husband also becomes a devotee over time, due to association.

The secret here is maturity. A lady who is fanatic and attached to externals will not work in this situation, but a lady who is more mature in her spiritual practice and can understand the difference between primary and secondary principles may find ways to adjust. Many people are nowadays vegetarian, and many will also not be against avoiding alcohol and drugs, as well as gambling, but of course, the fourth principle may be a problem in such cases. One will have to be flexible in this regard, and try to find some compromise, operating under the principle of being attentive to the partner's needs instead of strictly following a fixed set of rules.

Some argue that polygamy could be a solution to this problem of having more ladies than men, but as we discussed in a previous article, I believe this can cause more problems than it can solve. We can see that the final decision of Prabhupada was against it, and by studying the pros and cons we can easily understand why he decided so. More ladies than men in our movement also leads to serial polygamy (men divorcing and remarrying) which is in many senses even worse than regular polygamy, because it leads to abandoned women and neglected children. Devotee ladies marrying pious men from the outside and gradually making them devotees sound like a better idea. Even if there is a shortage of men in our movement, there are 4 billion men outside, and some of them are pious. I believe this is a possibility that could be better discussed.

Married life is always a compromise anyway, with even the most serious devotees having difficulties following a path of complete pure devotion in family life. In many cases, it may be easier to practice spiritual life with a partner who is supportive although not practicing very seriously, than with a judgmental or abusive "devotee" husband.