Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Akshat Namdeo's avatar

Prabhuji, in relation to bhagvatam and 5th canto especially, I had 13 doubts, and they are listed below. I would be very grateful if you looked into these and please clear my doubts, so that I'll be enlightened by your knowledge!

The questions are as follows -

1. Why is the story and history of writing Srimad Bhagavatam included in Srimad Bhagavatam? In other words, when Naradaji instructed Srila Vyasadeva to write Srimad Bhagvatam, and he wrote the Srimad Bhagavatam after getting guidance from Naradaji, why was this part included?

2. According to SB, Brahma is God of the Demigods (3.15.4), and Shiva is the greatest among Demigods (3.14.27), so who is greater? Brahmaji or Shivaji? (Because Brahmaji gave birth to Shivaji)

3. We know that creation and destruction of the material world is like a cycle, so before this world was created, it was destroyed. We also know that Shivaji is the cause of destruction, when he opens his third eye. So how did Shivaji exist before the creation of Brahmaji, as Brahmaji created Shivaji out of anger from the middle of his eyebrows? How did destruction take place before the existence of Shivaji?

4. Relating to the 3rd question, when Shivaji opens his 3rd eye, which of these gets annihilated? the universe we live in or the whole causal ocean?

5. What do the heads of Brahmaji depict? What does it mean when the SB says that our Brahmaji is the weakest one, and more powerful Brahmaji exist? In what sense their prowess is judged?

6. Do each of the millions of universes in the Causal Ocean have the same pastimes of Krishna, as he did in this world? Do all the universes have the same description of Krishna as the Sat - chit - ananda vigrah, and his beautiful Tribhanga form with Radharani and other paraphernalia? Is it constant for all the universes?

7. Related to the above question, do all universes have the same Srimad Bhagvatam, same rules, same regulations, same 8.4 million species, same structure of the universe like ours (14 planetary system), same incarnations?

8. Do the pastimes in our universe repeat after the death of Brahma and recreation? Are the same things repeated again and again?

9. Is the timeline of every universe the same? Do all the universes follow the time calculations like manvantaras, yugas systems like ours? Do all Universes at the same time have Krishna ji and all his paraphernalia, as we had, about 5,000 years ago?

10. Is the population of our universe constant? Or more people from the spiritual sky are falling here, and less people are going up?

11. According to SB, time does not exist in the spiritual sky. So if time doesn't exist, how is motion possible, and defined at all in the spiritual sky?

12. Consider a circle, with 4 divisions as quarters. We know that 1/4th part is material sky, and 3/4th part is Spiritual. Then how is the space defined outside the circle? What is after the limits of all of creation? (It's related to the question that space is expanding at a very fast speed, but where is it expanding into? Nothingness? What is it?)

13. According to Mahabharata, we have 64 dimensions. And we humans in this Universe can perceive only 3 dimensions. We know that Krishna ji was present on this very land for about 5,000 years, and people at that time have also seen him, touched him, perceived him. That implies that he came in 3 dimensions. But we know that Krishnaji is Purna Purusottama, he came on this earth with his full power. So he came with his full power, and the limit is 64 dimensions, and he was perceivable by normal people in 3 dimensions. This, in my mind, placed a contradiction. If people perceive him in 3 dimensions, that implies he didn't appear in 64 dimensions (because if he did, he would be unperceivable), but if he didn't appear in 64 dimensions, how he is still called Purna Purusottama, when he didn't use his full power?

Akshat Namdeo's avatar

Prabhuji, in relation to bhagvatam and 5th canto especially, I have a list of 11

No posts

Ready for more?